A Novel Bacterial Culture Media: Fruit Waste Agar

 

Dhiraj S. Girase*, Rahulsing G. Girase, Prasad P. Girase, Neha R. Jaiswal

Department of Microbiology, Ahinsa Institute of Pharmacy, Dhule Road, Dondaicha, 425408.

*Corresponding Author E-mail: dhirajr673@gmail.com

 

ABSTRACT:

The development of microbiology began in the 19th century with the invention of the culture medium. Bacterial culture was the first method to study human microbiota in 1860. Louis pasteur was the first to propagate bacteria on culture media. The culture media provides the essential nutrients such as carbohydrates, protein, vitamins and some growth factors for the proper development of bacteria. Nowadays, these growth medias are prepared by different expensive chemical ingredients in laboratories for research experiments, which ultimately makes our experiments expensive. Instead of using high-cost culture media, fruit waste material could prove to be a good alternate source for the production of low-cost media. The waste generated in household practices and kitchen includes vegetables and fruit waste. It is waste that almost every house generates every day. It can serve as a good source of nutrients and vitamins for in microorganisms. Hence these materials can be used to formulate solid media for the growth of bacteria. In the current study waste material like mango peels, banana peels, lemon peels and ground nut shell have been included to formulate the media. This material was collected from kitchen waste and vegetable market. Comparing the growth of organism (lactobacillus bulgaricus) standard commercial media and fruit waste with agar, it was found that the media prepared from fruit waste serves as a good and inexpensive source of nutrients for many bacteria. Thus, it can good be feather and used commercially for isolation and cultivation of various microorganisms.

 

KEYWORDS: Culture media, Bacteria, Fruit waste, Nutrients, Lactobacillus bulgaricus.

 

 


INTRODUCTION:

Microorganisms require basic nutrients, a source of energy and environmental conditions in order to grow and reproduce. Microorganism adopts habitats most suitable for their growth in the environment, to provide these requirements of microbes a 'culture medium’ was discovered by Louis Pasteur in 1860.1

 

To prepare medium for microorganism growth, the supply of carbon and energy sources and other growth factors is essential for the organisms. Depending on the nutritional growth requirements of microorganism, culture media are of different types.

 

The microorganism requires different macro elements likely C, H, O, N, S, P, K, Ca, Mg and Fe. For the synthesis of proteins, lipids, carbohydrates, nucleic acids. C, H, O, N, S and P are used. While K, Ca, Mg and Fe act as cell cations other elements like Mn, Zn, Co, Mo, Ni and Cu these are the part of enzymes and cofactors.2

 

Growth medium in its liquid state or solid state can be used to grow, enrich, observe and quantity microorganisms. Solid media can show the extraordinary colony characteristics shown by an organism while liquid medium can be used to obtain the high yield of enriched microorganism.3

 

A numerous type of culture media are utilized by the microbiologist to isolate, maintain grow the pure cultures and identify the bacteria according to their biochemical and physiological characteristics.4

 

Nutrient agar medium is frequently used as general-purpose medium for cultivation of wide range of bacteria. It is basically composed of peptone, meat extract, beef extra, sodium      chloride and agar.5

 

Commercially available media such, nutrient agar (NA), cetrimide agar, macconkey agar are used for the growth of microorganisms but these are very expensive.2

 

Scientists are making efforts continuously for finding an alternative source and culture media to design the cost-effective medium that can facilitate the growth of microorganism.

 

Waste management is a problem all over the world. Especially in developing countries like, India, increasing waste and managing its disposal is a big problem. 170000 tonnes of waste are generated in urban areas of India every day, 40- 60% of waste emanating in urban through household practices.6

 

This waste can be classified into two distinct forms like dry waste and wet waste. Wet waste generally contains organic waste. 2-3 thousand tonne of organic kitchen waste are generated per year which can become an effective resource for recovery of recyclable materials. Wet organic waste emanating from kitchen and household practices includes fruits and vegetable wastes like peels, pulp, seed, pomace, stems, pods etc. Such waste is rich in carbohydrates and other nutrients which are used by microorganism n alternative source for the cultivation microorganisms.7

 

The fruit wastes such as mango peel and ground nut shell can be a good source of nutrients of nutrients for the growth of bacteria as it contains simple and complex sugars that are metabolize by microorganisms.

 

It also contains other nutrients such as protein, fiber, carbohydrate and ions like sodium, potassium, magnesium, calcium, iron, zinc and phosphorus etc.8

 

The increasing cost of culture media has necessitated continuous search for replacing the commercial media with cheap alternative media.  Considering the commercial media 100 gm of nutrient agar powder cost approximately 330/- in India (hi media laboratories, Mumbai) thus 1kg of this media costs around 3,300/-.9

 

The problem of waste management can be overcome by utilizing the waste at large scale for the production of culture media. This can also minimize the problem of costly commercial media by using natural media prepared by using the fruit waste and vegetable waste. Standard procedures in any microbiological laboratories require large number of media for techniques like isolation, enrichment, spread plate technique and several other experiments. Thus, low-cost media rich in nutrients, giving reproducible result is need of the day.

 

Types of culture media:10

The culture medias are classified in many ways-

1)   Based on physical state:

A) Liquid media

B) Semi solid media

C) Solid media

 

2)   On the basis of presence of molecular oxygen and reducing substances in the media:

A) Aerobic media

B) Anaerobic media

 

3)   Based on nutritional factors:

A) Simple media

B) Complex media

C) Synthetic media

D) Special media.

 

Nutritional Requirements of Bacteria:11

In order to grow well, bacteria need at least nutrients such as water, a carbon source, a nitrogen source and mineral salts.

 

1) Water:

Water plays vital role in solubilizing nutrients, transporting them and ensuring hydrolysis reactions. Some bacteria require free water for their growth.

 

2) Carbon sources:

Carbon is main constituent element in bacteria, it is essential for the synthesis of molecules such as fats, carbohydrates, proteins and nucleic acids. Bacteria can get carbon from inorganic carbon sources, such as carbon dioxide or organic sources such as sugars and alcohols.

 

3) Nitrogen sources:

They are numerous and can be found in a large number of compositions of culture medium. It is found the in organic form, corresponding protein hydrolysates. Nitrogen allows bacteria to synthesize their proteins. Finally, among the common mineral salts, phosphate, sulphate, magnesium or calcium are regularly found.

 

4) Growth factors or bacterial vitamins:

Some species of bacteria requires organic compounds in minimum amount for growth which is called as growth factors or bacterial vitamins. Some bacteria have ability to synthesize their entire requirement of vitamins from culture medium. Some species cannot synthesize the vitamins from media and don’t show growth in the absence of vitamins so, they are must be added in media. 12

Nutrient agar (NA) is commonly used as general-purpose medium for the growth of a cultivation of broad range of bacteria. It is mainly composed of peptic digest of animal tissue, beef extract and yeast extract, sodium chloride and agar. Commercially available media such as nutrient agar (NA), cetrimide agar macconkey agar are also used for the growth of microorganisms but they are very expensive.

 

In this research project we are developing alternative and cost-effective culture media using fruit waste like, mango peels, banana peels, lemon peels and ground shell. These waste materials were procured from household waste and local market. This is further processed and used in the formulation of culture media. Such waste is rich in carbohydrates, proteins and other nutrients which are easily utilized by the microorganisms. The nutrient agar (NA) is used in this project as standard media to compare the growth of formulated media

 

Isolation Methods for Pure Cultures: 13

1) Streak plate method:

The bacterial cells are deposited on media by the establishment of gradient across the face of the petri plate. This method is utilized to isolate the pure cultures of bacteria. Small sample of test culture is placed and streaked across the plate surface with the help of inoculation loop and the plates placed for the incubation.

 

 

Fig.1 Streak Plate Method 25

 

2) Pour plate method:

In this technique, the mixed culture of bacterium is diluted directly within the liquid agar medium tube (42-45°c) and mixed well. During this technique, mounted quantity of inoculant (generally one ml) from a broth/sample is placed within the center of sterile petri dish employing

 

A sterile measuring device. The contents of every tube area unit poured into separate petri plates and so allowed to solidify. Finally, isolated the colonies and area unit picked up by immunization loop and patterned onto another petri plate to insure purity. This technique is additionally used for determinative the quantity of viable microorganism cells.

 

Fig.2 Pour Plate Method26

 

3) Spread plate method:

The principle of this technique involves employing a sterilized spreader with a sleek surface product of metal or glass to use a tiny low quantity of microorganism suspended in an exceeding resolution over a plate that must be dry and at temperature in order that the agar will absorb the

 

Microorganism a lot of pronto. A productive unfold plate can have enumerable range of isolated microorganism colonies equally distributed on the plate.

 

Fig.3 Spread Plate Method27

 

Sterilization Method of Culture Media and Apparatus: 14

The culture media and apparatus are generally sterilized by Autoclave method which is a sealed device (similar to a pressure cooker) that kills microorganisms.

 

Principle:

The use of moist heat facilitates the killing of all microorganisms, including heat-resistant endospores which are achieved by heating the materials inside the device at temperatures above the boiling point of water.

 

The usual procedure is to heat at 1.1 kilograms/square centimeter (kg/cm2) [15 pounds/square inch (lb/in2)] steam pressure, which yields a temperature of 121°C. At 121°c, the time of autoclaving to achieve sterilization is generally considered to be 15-20 min, depending on the volume of the load.  To make sure, sterilization is successful one should ensure:

1)    Air should be evacuated so that the chamber fills with steam.

2)    Articles should be placed in the autoclave so that steam can easily penetrate them.

 

Fig. 4 Autoclave 28

 

MATERIAL AND METHODS:

1) Mango peels powder:15,16

 

Fig. 5 Mango peel powder.

 

Genus: Mangifera.

Biological source: A mango is an edible stone fruit obtain from mangifera indica plant.

Family: Anacardiaceae.

Synonym: Mangifera indica.

 

Nutrients present- Mango peel contains a variety of macronutrients (total carbohydrates (20-30%), protein, amino acids, lipids, organic acids as well as dietary fiber) and micronutrients. Dietary fiber is important functional nutrient it ranges between 16% to 28%. The content of vitamin c ranges from 188-2570 µg/g. The mango peel contains significantly higher levels of minerals than pulp of the following minerals Ca, K, Mg, Na, Fe, Mn, Zn, Cu.

 

2) Banana peels powder:17, 18

 

Fig. 6 Banana peel powder.

 

Genus:

Musa.

 

Family:

Musaceae.

 

Biological source:

A banana is an elongated, edible fruit botanically berry-produced by several kinds of large herbaceous flowering plant.

 

Nutrients:

Significant quantities of banana peels, equivalent to 40% of the total weight of fresh banana are generated as waste. It contains following nutrients per 100gm., protein 7.57±0.30gm 10.0% fiber, 68.39 carbohydrate and macronutrients like Na 0.18 gm/100 gm, 9.39 gm/100gm potassium 0.71gm/100gm magnesium, 0.44 ± 0.08g/ants in the genus musa.

 

Synonym:

Musa coccinea, musa velutina. 100mi calcium, 96.50 mg/kg iron, 27.95mg/kg zinc, 0.09gm/100gm phosphorus.

 

3) Groundnut shell powder:19, 20

 

Fig. 7 Ground nut shell powder.

 

Genus:

Arachis.

 

Biological source:

It obtain from the plants faboideae, subfamily of the legumes which grow and ripen underground.

 

Family:

Fabaceae

 

Synonyms:

Peanut, goober, pindar.

 

Nutrients:

It includes 0.50% crude protein. 59.0% crude fiber, 4.43% carbohydrate. Sodium (42.00mg/100 gm) potassium (705.11mg/100gm), magnesium (3.98.00 mg/100gm) calcium (2.28 mg/100gm), iron (6.97mg/ 100gm), zinc (3.20mg/100gm), phosphorus (10.55 mg/100gm) are all abundant in groundnut shells.

 

4) Lemon peel powder:21,22,23

 

Fig. 8 Lemon peels powder.

 

Genus:

Citrus.

 

Biological source:

The lemon (citrus limon) is a species of small evergreen trees in the flowering plant family rutaceae.

 

Family:

Rutaceae

 

Synonyms:

Citrus limon, citrus aurantium subsp. Bergamia.

 

Nutrients:

The lemon peel contains the protein (1.5gm/100gm), fibre (11gm/100gm), carbohydrate (16gm/100gm) and macro elements, sodium. (1.99mg/100g), potassium (127mg/100gm), magnesium (11.50mg/100gm), calcium (31.8mg/100gm), iron (0.34mg/100gm), zinc (0.01mg/100gm), phosphorus (23.9mg/100gm). It includes other growth factors like, vitamin a and e, vitamin b.

 

5) Sodium chloride (Nacl): 24

 

Fig. 9 Sodium chloride (Nacl)

 

Sodium chloride is the most well-known salt and consists of a single sodium ion that is bonded to a single chlorine ion. The presence of sodium chloride in nutrient agar maintains a salt concentration in the medium that is similar to the cytoplasm of microorganisms. If the salt concentration is not similar osmosis takes place transporting excess water into or out from the cell. Both of these scenarios can be led to the death of the cell.

 

6) Agar: 24

 

 

Fig. 10 Agar

A large proportion of culture media are consisting of the chemical agar. Agar is a gelatinous mixture that is extracted from seaweed. Agar consists of mixture of polymers (polysaccharides), where the basic sugar is galactose and it is used to solidify the medium.

 

7) Water:

Water makes up a large proportion of media. Water is essential for the growth and reproduction of microorganisms and also provides the medium through which various nutrients can be transported.

 

METHODOLOGY:

1)    Collection of raw materials:

The waste materials such as mango peels, banana peels, lemon peels and ground but shell were procured from kitchen waste and vegetable market. One kilogram of each waste material was collected. Samples were brought to the laboratory using sterile plastic bags for further processing.

 

2)    Processing of waste material:

The waste of fruits was washed two to three times with sterile distilled water to remove any dust or soil particles. They were then cut into small pieces using a sterile knife.

 

3)    Formation of powder:

The raw material was sun dried for 3-4 days. Dried raw materials were ground by using electronic blender to obtain its powdered form. Each powder was sieved through sieve no. #100 to obtain finer particles of the powder and then stored in clean and dry plastic containers.

 

4)    Test organism used:

Lactobacillus bulgaricus

 

5)    Formulation of media:

One gram of powder of each ingredient was added in four conical flask (100ml) containg 20ml warm water which was kept for overnight to obtain its natural extract. This extract was filtered and filtrate use according to following formula, one by one all ingredients was added in water with heating and stirring and volume was makeup upto 100ml. pH of culture media was maintain at 7±0.5

 

Formula table for 100 ml:

Table 1. Ingredient formula

Sr. No

Ingredients

F1

F2

1.

Mango peel extract

5 ml

5 ml

2.

Banana peel extract

5 ml

5 ml

3.

Lemon peel extract

5 ml

5 ml

4.

Groundnut peel extract

5 ml

5 ml

5.

Sodium chloride (Nacl)

2.5 gm

2.5 gm

6.

Agar

3 gm

2 gm

7.

Water

Q. S

Q. S

 

Fig. 11 Extraction of powder

 

Fig. 12 Formulated media

 

6)    Sterilization of media and apparatus:

The media and apparatus were sterilized by autoclave method. This technique works on the principle of moist heat sterilization. It kills the microorganisms by the irreversible denaturation of enzymes and structural proteins. The media and apparatus were wrapped with the paper and placed in autoclave for sterilization at 121°c for 20 minutes under 15 psi pressure and were poured into sterile petri dishes separately.

 

Fig. 13 Media and petri dish wrapped with paper

 

Fig. 14 Autoclave

 

7)    Isolation of bacterial species: 

The lactobacillus bulgaricus bacteria was taken from curd sample. These bacteria were isolated on newly prepared fruit waste agar as well as standard commercial media nutrient agar (prepared by mixing the components obtained from Himedia, Mumbai) using the streak plate method. The plates were incubated at 37°C for 24-48 hours in incubator. After the incubation these plates was observed and compared with standard nutrient agar (NA) for bacterial growth.

 

RESULT:

Procurement, processing and preparation of powdered form of raw waste materials:

 

 

all the raw materials were procured and processed to obtain powdered form.The  fruit waste agar media  was formulated by two formulaes ( F1 and F2 ). Out of this two formulae, the ‘f1’ formulae supported the growth of lactobasillus bacteria. Bacterial growth was better and requies less time to solidify  on ‘F1’ formulation while ‘F2’ formulation require  more time to solidify due to less concentration of agar. The bacterial growth was faster on fruit waste agar. The bacterial culture showed growth after 24 hours on this media while on nutrient agar (NA) it took 48 hours to show the growth at 37℃. As shown in figure. Below, lactobasillus bulgaricus bacteria showed luxuriant growth than the nutrient agar (NA) media within 24 hours. Which later was confirmed on the electronic microscope at 45x power lens.

 

Fig. 15 Standard media (nutrient agar)

 

Fig. 16 Formulated media.

 

Fig. 17 Bacteria in compound microscope.

 

Fig. 18 Bacteria in electron.

 

Characteristics of powder:

1)    Organoleptic properties:

 the organoleptic properties of mango peel powder, banana peel powder, lemon peel powder, ground nut shell powder was evaluated for their appearance, color, order, texture and smoothness shown in the below table1.

2)    Particle size:

Particle size of mango peel powder, banana peel powder, lemon peel powder, ground nut shell powder was determined by sieving method with help of sieve shaker machine shown in the below table 1.

 

3)    Bulk density and tapped density:

The bulk density and tapped density of mango peel powder, banana peel powder, lemon peel powder, groundnut shell powder was determined with the help of bulk density apparatus shown in the below table 1.

 

4)    Flow property:

The flow property of mango peel powder, banana peel powder, lemon peel powder, ground nut shell powder was determined by the method of angle of repose. Most of them showed excellent flow property shown in the below table 1.

 

5)    pH:

The pH of all ingredient powder was determined by pH paper method. The paper was dipped in solution of powder and color change compared with standard pH range shown in the below table 1.

 

6)    Solubility:

The solubility of powder was checked in water and all ingredients was soluble in water shown in the below table 1.


Table 1.  Powder characteristics

Sr. No

Parameter

Mango peel

Banana peel

Groundnut shell

Lemon peel

1.

Appearance

Powder

Powder

Powder

Powder

2.

Color

Yellow

Brownish

Light yellow

Pale yellow

3.

Odor

Characteristics

Characteristics

Slight

Characteristics

4.

Texture

Moderate fine

Fine

Fine

Very fine

5.

Smoothness

Smooth

Smooth

Smooth

Smooth

6.

Particle size

180 ± 20 µm

150 ± 10 µm

150 ± 10 µm

150 ± 10 µm

7.

Bulk density

0.52 gm/ml

0.40 gm/ml

0.21 gm/ml

0.49 gm/ml

8.

Tapped density

0.60 gm/ml

0.57gm/ml

O.27 gm/ml

0.5 gm/ml

9.

Flow property

(angle of repose)

Excellent (24.22º)

Excellent (27.47º)

Excellent (25.64º)

Fair

(36.50º)

10.

pH

3-5

7-9

9-12

4-6

11.

Solubility

Water soluble

Water soluble

Water soluble

Water soluble

 


DISCUSSION:

Cultivation of industrially important microorganisms requires large amount of growth media. Scientists have also concluded that the media formulated using organic waste can prove to be the replacement for the high- cost commercial media; Deivanayaki et.al formulated the media using the vegetables like tomato, carrot, cabbage and pumpkin. It supported the growth of bacteria and fungi in very less time as compared to commercially available growth media. Pratibha jadhav et.al showed that fruit waste and vegetable waste like cauliflower stalk, potato peel, fenugreek stem and orange peel have been used in formulation of cheap alternative media which supported the growth of bacteria. Sayali daptardar et.al used kitchen waste to formulate the media; it included pomegranate peels, sweet lime and orange pomace, peapods and spinach in the formulation of media for the cultivation of fungi.

 

CONCLUSION:

Waste recycling is the best method of waste management. In the current study, fruit waste was used to formulate medium that can be used in every day undergraduate laboratory practices for the bacterial growth, the newly synthesized medium was named ‘fruit waste agar’. When compared for the growth of the bacterial culture with that commercially available media (nutrient agar), it was observed that the test organism (lactobacillus bulgaricus) grew faster and luxuriantly on fruit waste agar than the commercially available (Nutrient agar) media in the market. In fact, fruit waste agar took only 24 hours of incubation for the growth of bacteria, unlike the nutrient agar (NA) media requires 48 hours. Thus use of this medium can prove to be very cost effective and environmental friendly.

 

Many industries require large amount of dehydrated media for cultivation of industrially important organism within short time on large scale and also the commercially available media used for microbial cultivation is very much costly that it may not be affordable for lab purpose. There are several studies which have tried replacing commercial media with cheap alternative media. Considering the commercial media, 100 grams of   nutrient agar (NA) powder (Himedia) costs approx. Rs. 1000/- in India. Thus 1kg of this media costs around rs. 9 to 10k. The agar-agar powder of 500 grams quantity cost for approximately Rs. 4000/- in India. Considering the cost of agar-agar powder used to formulate the fruit waste agar and all the procedures involved in it, it can be easily estimated that the fruit waste agar is a way cheaper than commercial media.

 

REFERENCES:

1.      M. Bornet, j.c lagier et.al, bacterial culture through selective and non-selective conditions: the evolution of culture media in clinical mirobiology (2020): 24(c)

2.      Pratibha jadhav, maunalini sonne, aratí kadam, suraj patil, kirti dahigaonkar, jaspal kaur oberoi (2017): 10(2).

3.      Sayali Daptardar, Darshana kankoshe, Shubhangi Salunke, Aman Dubey and Ashwini Rathod. Kitchen waste agar: A novel media for fungal cultivation (2018): 6(2): 2320- 2882.

4.      John Lindquist, 2006, General microbiology A lab manual. 4th edition, mcgraw Hill primes custom publishing)

5.      Hi Media Laboratories, Mumbai, Technical Data

6.      Sunil Kumar, Stephen R. Smith, Geoff Fowler, costas velis, S. Jyoti kumar, Shashi Arya, Rena, Rakesh kumar and Christopher cheeseman. Challenges and oppurtunities associated with waste managment in india (2017):4: 160764

7.      Janet I, Issac O, Mary N and Ijeeoma. Utilization of food crop wastes for the formulation of laboratory media used for cultivating soil fungi (2014): 2(1): 010-014)

8.      Saheed Ok, Jamal P. Karim MIA, Alam Z, Muyibi SA. Cellulolytic, fruits: A potential support for enzyme assisted protein production (2013); 13(5): 379-385

9.      Dievanayaki M, Antony Iruthayaraj P, Alternative vegitable nutrient source for microbial growth. (2012): 2(5): 47-51.

10.   Ayesha Fatema Sayed, Culture Media and culture methods (2022) DOI: 10.13140 |RG22 27 20441.60009)

11.   Power DA Johnson JA. Bitco™ and BBLTM manual, 2nd ed. Sparks: Becton, dikinson and Company; 2009)

12.   Prof. Chandrakant kakore. Phamaceutical microbiology book, Nirali prakashan, 1st ed. (2018), Page No- 2.17

13.   Dr. Kuntal Das, A text book. Of pharmaceutical microbiology, Second edition. (February 2019), Nirali prakashan, page no. 1.33

14.   https://microbenotes.com/autoclave/

15.   Veeranjaneya Reddy Labaka, Young-jung Wee, weibing Ye and Mallikarjuna korivi, Natritional composition and Bioctive Compounds in three different parts of mango fruit (2021): 18,741

16.   https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mangifera_

17.   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana

18.   Ahmed M. Aboul enein et.al. Identification of phenolic compounds from banana peels (Musa paradaia L.) As ntioxidant and antimicrobial agents (2016): 8(4):46-55)

19.   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peanut

20.   Graudnut shells as a potential as feed supplement for ruminants on pasteures: A review. India Journal of animal research (2022): (56):521-524

21.   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemon

22.   https://www.nutritionvalue.org/lemon_Peel

23.   Anna Czech, Ewa zarycka et.al. Mineral content of the Pulp and Peel of various citous Past Cultivos (2020): 193: 555-563)

24.   htpps://Sciencing.com/chemical-composition-nutrient-agar-14135.html

25.   https://microbenotes.com/streak-plate-method-principle-methods-significance-limitations/

26.   https://biologyreader.com/isolation-of-bacteria.html

27.   https://noteshippo.com/spread-plate-method-in-microbiology-principle-procedure-uses-and-limitations/

28.   https://microbonline.com/autoclave-principle-procedure-types-and-uses/

 

 

 

Received on 11.08.2022         Modified on 24.08.2022

Accepted on 12.09.2022     ©A&V Publications All right reserved

Res.  J. Pharmacology and Pharmacodynamics.2022;14(4):225-233.

DOI: 10.52711/2321-5836.2022.00039